Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon - Release Date Investigation

October 10th, 1993.
That is the release date associated with the US release of Link: The Faces of Evil and Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon. It's a release month/day they share with esteemed gaming events such as The Orange Box and that release party of Doom II that everyone thinks is the actual release date of the game and not September 30th. In addition, it's associated with a December 25th, 1993 release date in Europe.

This date appeared on the Internet one fine day, and everyone assumed it was real without actually checking. Until now. I've went through multiple contemporary sources regarding the CD-i and the Animation Magic Zelda games, much like my debunking of the Hotel Mario and Zelda's Adventure release dates, and I've come to a conclusion:

The evidence I currently have does NOT rule that date out.

Sections:

File Date Checkup -- A Lack of Magazine Coverage -- Newspaper Clues -- The Release Window As Of Writing

File Date Checkup

As per the other games, my first step was doing a general file date checkup on the disc. If the release date was older than the last updated file, then something funny was going on. To reuse a passage from my Hotel Mario release date investigation:

"A cool feature about CD/DVD-based games is that the files stored on their disk reflect the last time they were updated. For example, the released version of Zelda's Adventure had its last files updated on March 27th, 1995, while Link: The Faces of Evil's latest file date was June 24th, 1993. This is handy as it both points to when a specific game went gold and disproves any "release date" that occurred before it."

So, what's up with Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon?

There's... a bit to unpack here. First off, those file dates for the European dubbed versions are rather late in the year. While it could be possible for a rushed mid-late December release date to happen, there's a higher chance it was pushed back to early 1994, allowing enough time for proper publishing and barely missing out the Christmas rush. Choose whatever year you prefer - they're not going to get more fine-tuned than this, at least until some more concrete evidence shows up.

Most importantly, the English version (used for both the US and Europe) is dated before both of the online release dates, which doesn't help much with the investigation. It might be a hint that the two regions got Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon around the same time, but that's about it...
Still, it's a start. We have a lower boundary to work with, and that's better than nothing. Onto the magazine coverage!

And here's where we run into a problem.

A Lack of Magazine Coverage

For the first couple years of its lifespan, the CD-i was not a popular console; its less-than-stellar lineup ensured that there was little coverage of it from both gaming and electronics magazines. Things started picking up when the console got an actual game library, which only really started around 1994. By then, both the Digital Video Cartridge and the Animation Magic Zelda games had been released.
Do you see the problem here?

Because of a lack of CD-i coverage before 1994, there's also a lack of Animation Magic Zelda coverage around the time of its release. The only related announcement that magazines actually picked up on was the CD-i/Nintendo collaboration, which didn't give any release dates for its titles. This isn't good... are there any publications that bothered to give the games a release window??

Well, after some deep scouring, I was able to find two (arguably three) mentions of Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon's release from magazine and magazine-adjacent publications. Thank goodness! Let's start with the one (maybe two) from the magazine Electronic Games:

The first relevant mention is in the September 1993 issue. In a section about the CD-i's upcoming titles, it notes that "revamped versions of Nintendo's Link games" are one of them. Remember, monthly magazines are written in the month before their cover date - therefore, this was likely written in August. The mention of only Link is very odd, but it might just be them calling the series by the main protagonist's name like they did with Mario.
The second mention comes in the December 1993 issue, where it states that both Animation Magic Zelda games were released in the fall. Fall happens from September 1st or 22nd to either November 30th or December 21st, depending on what system you use. We can safely eliminate the December date due to the aforementioned cover date rule.

That's great! This one magazine helps narrow down the search to Fall 1993, between September 1st and November 30th. For fun, let's check out that other source and see what it has to say.

The source is this lovely advertisement for the Philips CD-i on the Electronics Boutique Christmas 1993 catalog - on the second page, no less! Among its featured titles are Link: The Faces of Evil and Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon, using their early game blurbs too!! Radical!!!

This advertisement for the CD-i appears to be part of a Christmas 1993 push by Philips to popularize the console in the United States. Apart from the catalog, it was featured in a Macy's "Power Weekend" sale, as well as a Sears newspaper ad campaign spanning several cities across several states. Back to the catalog - it was published in December, and the previous Electronics Boutique catalog was in October and did not feature the CD-i or the Animation Magic Zelda games. Assuming they follow the cover date rules, this gives a rough timeframe of the Christmas catalog (and CD-i section) being written from late September to late November. It's nice to have some confirmation for the range I inferred from Electronic Games' issues.

But can we do better? I think we can... but we'll need to dive into those old newspapers I pulled those pages out of.

Newspaper Clues

Now, the issue with doing online old newspaper digging is that, like, half of them are archived by the Ancestry.com conglomerate, and they charge you to view their archives in full. Fortunately, the other (like) half is archived by Google, which is a conglomerate that does NOT charge you to view them. For the purposes of this section, that's good.

Another issue is that the scans aren't so great, and this leads to text transcription errors. Furthermore, if the text is small enough, it'll be blurry and unable to be picked up by a word search. So, in what amounted to about five hours of searching every relatable term I could think of, I was only able to find two mentions of Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon between the late September and late November timeframe.

The first one is dated November 11th, 1993, and comes from Page 4A of the Florence, Alabama newspaper "Times Daily". It's essentially an advertisement for the CD-i at the furniture store Story & Lee. Among the discs labeled as being in stock are Link: The Faces of Evil and Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon. It's very obvious that, by this point, the Animation Magic Zelda games had hit retail. We can narrow down the latest date they were available to November 11th, 1993.

The second one is dated October 15th, 1993, and comes from an advertisement bundled with the Sarasota, Florida newspaper "Sarasota Herald-Tribune". In an advertisment detailing a Home Electronics Expo at the defunct furniture store chain Roberds, the Philips CD-i is promoted with "Zelda & Link" as a featured attraction. The thing here is that it doesn't actually specify if the games were available for sale at the expo, or if the two games were demonstrations only. And I doubt anyone remembers if they bought a Philips CD-i with the Zelda games from this specific expo.
At the very least, stores were using Link: The Faces of Evil and Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon to promote the CD-i by October 15th.

And that's all the evidence I've scrounged up so far.

The Release Window As Of Writing

With my findings, I will now display the most likely periods in which Zelda: The Wand of Gamelon released:

If you've made it this far, thank you for reading my unhinged CD-i release date ramblings! What this page needs more than anything are contemporary reviews and evidence of the game's release date.
Especially those dubbed releases.
If you have either/or, let me know as soon as possible. I'd love to crack this 30-years-old case.